I'll start out with this: They sent the right people home ... and I think that everyone would agree. As for everything else, I have to admit that I was a little disappointed. With the blog being "blocked" by spam seeking robots, and a heavy project that I am knee deep in, I've had very little time to watch television leaving me completely free of any episode teasers HGTV might have aired during the week. So when I sat down, ice cream in hand, to watch this weeks episode I was excited to see how the designers would handle this challenge.
The idea was to make useable, livable space out of a detached garage, evidently while keeping the function of a garage, i.e., those ugly doors can not be replaced by a series of gorgeous french doors (*le sigh!) No matter, the interior space roughly 20x17 was essentially a blank canvas and in theory fantastic design still could be made. Both spaces were your average garage detached from a home built in the 1930's. Nothing redeemable.
So, of course there are teams. Team 1 = Dan (my fave), Nathan (my second fave), Tashika, and Lonnie. Team 2 = Jamie, Tori, Antonio, and Jason. Immediately I think: "Wow, Dan and Nathan on the same team, they'll do a great job - even with Tashika." But the fact of the matter is, they didn't - and I don't think that they would have, even without Tashika. The owners described their interior as eclectic, but they appreciated the 1930's Spanish courtyard style of their home. They wanted a space where they could watch television, entertain, be a family, but most importantly felt like an interior room. The finished product:
It's not the fact that they left it partially unfinished due to the myriad of delays they encountered, the look here is (in my humble opinion) restaurant spanish. That look that you see in any middle of the road spanish restaurant. The sunwashed color, the dark and heavy wood: and those elements alone aren't bad - but together, it's too expected.
What I loved:
- Using the fabric on the back wall. Whether it was Tashika's idea or someone elses really doesn't matter - it was a great way to diffuse that and create texture, interest, and depth in that space.
- I wouldn't have created the sunken living area in this space. As Vern said, the height of the garage was questionable without the addition of the platform. And anyone who saw the show, watched the husband duck almost 2' to get onto the platform from the door. I think that the idea was great, and it was a good way to deal with the uneven floor, just not in this space. We have to remember that the "white room" challenges are really the time and place to show off the creative theory. Residential projects like the 2nd challenge kitchens, and now this garage, are spaces that are left for people to use, enjoy, and ultimately appreciate as finished spaces. I would have simply shimmed out the floor with exterior pressure treated lumber to make it as level as possible, then layed decking timbers to create the look of a hardwood floor. That could have then been painted black, because even with wear, it would have fit nicely into the Spanish style the homeowners were looking for.
- I would have replaced the garage door with something that had more windows to let light into the room.
- I would have painted the interior timbers of the garage and the entire "cieling" the same color as the walls (an antique white, or soft muted bisque color) to create a false sense of height.
The family of the second space, well the wife anyway, really wanted a sophisticated Hampton's feel for a home office / family room / work out space / gameroom / theatre / slash slash slash. You name it - she wanted it, and why not? Here you have the eyes of fresh, young, talented designers working with your space - I'd probably be sure to tell them to hang the moon, too! The finished space:
Team 2 definitely did a better job. The white floor, the soft green on the walls (which picks up as blue here because of the seafoam color, it appeared more green on television, and was described as a light sage by the group) the seagrass rug. In my opinion, they really gave the homeowner what they were looking for here, albeit text book Hamptons.
What I loved:
- The color.
- The idea of doing a white floor, with the seagrass rug.
- That they gave the owner the television, office, gathering, and exercise space they asked for.
What I would have done differently:
- Again, I would have painted the interior ceiling of this space. (Probably white)
- I would have left the wainscotting white, and had the color only on the upper portion of the wall space.
- I would have done more with the back wall (behind the sofa), that mirror sure seems lonely, don't you think?
Now, I cringed when I heard the homeowner say: this looks like a set up from a furniture store. I certainly understand that one-stop shopping was the best way to handle their time constraints, and budget concerns, but ...
I will say that I am happy for anyone who got the opportunity to be a part of this season. Television, in particular, HGTV is a wonderful opportunity to show everything you've got, and with that sort of weight, it's obvious that some people will make mistakes that they wouldn't have otherwise. HGTV exec.'s, picked these folks for a reason - and looking at the online portfolio's of many of them, they're all very talented. My thoughts are not meant, in anyway, to depreciate the hard work of any of the designers.
With that out of the way ... I was so excited to read the comments you all left on the chair teaser from last week. I left the chair as it was, but used it in a design project that I just finished last night. I'll get the before and after's ready for posting tomorrow!